Print

Training >> Browse Articles >> Patrol

+5

Plain View Doctrine

Jack Ryan

The plain view doctrine is an exception to the warrant requirement which allows officers to seize items which they observe and immediately recognize as evidence or contraband while they are lawfully present in an area protected by the 4th Amendment. The foundation case providing the elements of a plain view seizure as related to the plain view doctrine is Horton v. California. In Horton, a police officer had probable cause to believe that evidence of a robbery existed at a house. While the officer had probable cause to believe the proceeds of the robbery as well as the weapons used in the robbery would be found in the house to be searched, the magistrate issued a search warrant for only the proceeds. Upon executing the search warrant, the officers discovered the weapons in “plain view” and immediately recognized the weapons as evidence of the robbery.

Horton, argued that since the police knew about the weapons prior to the search, the weapons should not be admitted under plain view because their discovery was not “inadvertent.” The Supreme Court used the Horton case to eliminate any requirement that the discovery be inadvertent. The Court pointed out that one must distinguish a plain observation (which may provide probable cause) from a plain view doctrine seizure as an exception to the warrant requirement. In its conclusion the Court held that a plain view doctrine seizure has three elements. First, the officer must already be lawfully present in an area protected by the 4th Amendment, second, the item must be out in plain view, and third, the officer must immediately recognize the item as evidence or contraband without making a further intrusion.

What constitutes a further intrusion was explained in Arizona v. Hicks. In Hicks, police responded to a shooting where a man in a first floor apartment had been injured by a bullet fired through the floor of Hicks’ apartment above. The officers entered Hicks’ apartment based upon exigent circumstances and seized three guns and a ski mask. During the search, one of the officers noticed some expensive stereo equipment in this apartment. The officer moved the stereo equipment in order to obtain serial numbers. Upon running a check on the serial numbers the officer discovered that a turntable had been taken in a robbery. On appeal to the Supreme Court, the officer argued that the stolen turntable had been in plain view. The Court concluded that the officer did not have probable cause to believe that the turntable was evidence or contraband until he made a further intrusion by moving the items to obtain the numbers. The movement was a further search unrelated to the original exigent circumstance of looking for guns and evidence of the shooting.

Thus, the significant elements in any plain view doctrine seizure are: (1) the officer must already have lawful presence in an area protected by the 4th Amendment. In a house, that would mean that the officer must have entered with a warrant, exigency or consent. (2) The officer must observe an item in plain view. (3) The officer must immediately recognize the item as evidence or contraband without making a further intrusion. It should be recognized that officers routinely make plain view observations, but that does not necessarily mean that the item may be seized unless the officer has met the elements above.

A case from Ohio points out that lawful presence in an area protected by the 4th Amendment is essential to the plain view doctrine. In Ohio v. Cooper, police investigating a robbery developed Cooper as a suspect. Knowing that Cooper had an outstanding arrest warrant on an unrelated matter, the police went to Cooper’s house and knocked on the door. Cooper answered the door and either stepped onto the porch or stood in the doorway leading to the porch as police informed him that they had a warrant for him and suspected him of the robbery. The officers handcuffed Cooper and then brought him inside the house and had him sit on a couch. One of the officers observed a blue jacket that he believed to be the same jacket worn by the robber in a videotape of the robbery. The jacket was seized in plain view. Cooper challenged the use of the jacket as evidence by arguing that the police, who apprehended him on his porch or in his doorway, did not have lawful presence in his home.

Most Popular

In analyzing the case, the court noted that the officers provided no justification for entering the home other than reporting that they entered the home to effectuate the arrest. The court observed that the arrest had already been accomplished on the porch and therefore it was unnecessary to enter the home to effectuate the arrest. The court concluded that the officers were not “lawfully present” inside the home when the plain view observation was made and thus, the jacket was inadmissible. The court also rejected the prosecution’s use of a subsequent consent search to save the jacket. The court concluded that the consent was tainted by the unlawful entry.

The court also examined the admissibility of a statement made by Cooper during his arrest. While in the home, Cooper was told a second time that he was a suspect in a robbery to which he responded that it was only a theft and not a robbery and that he only had a BB gun. Although the officers had not expressly questioned Cooper, the court concluded that the detective’s statement to Cooper regarding the fact that he was a suspect in the robbery (on two occasions during the arrest), constituted the “functional equivalent of interrogation” which was recognized in Rhode Island v. Innis. The functional equivalent of interrogation is conduct or words by an officer, which the officer knows or should know is likely to produce an incriminating response. After concluding that Cooper was the subject of interrogation, while in the custody of 9 police officers that were in the house, the court suppressed the statements since Cooper had not been Mirandized.


+5
  • Sdc10514_max50

    stingray67s

    almost 3 years ago

    2 Comments

    That is a great question! maxweve1. It seems to me that during the past 2 years of Criminal Investigations studies that is a questionable situation. There are a great deal of smells out there and will smell give you probable cause to search without consent? Of course there is ways around that if the driver is being pulled over for driving violations and you suspect he / she is under the influence of a substance. Send for the proper documentation and wait if you are unsure. I believe you could have response while testing the suspect for possible influence. Its sketchy but possible depending on reason for pulling the car over.

  • Columbusga_max50

    maxweve1

    about 3 years ago

    6 Comments

    Question: upon conducting a traffic stop, you smell the odor of recently burnt marijuana. Does that give you probable cause to search the interior of the vehicle without consent?

  • Photo_user_blank_big

    Fastwork

    over 3 years ago

    4 Comments

    I only think about to me actual taking an opportunity to become a police it feels like first kiss! lol i feeling strong and stop while I'm nothing. I also want to to be a cop car once I grow! haha just joking.
    Weight loss tips

  • Photo_user_blank_big

    fantutu

    over 3 years ago

    2 Comments

    hey,this is one of the best posts that I’ve ever seen; you may include some more ideas in the same theme. I’m still waiting for some interesting thoughts from your side in your next post.
    http://www.newbagonsale.com/ designer handbagss
    http://www.newbagonsale.com/christmas-gifts/ Christmas gifts
    http://www.newbagonsale.com/repliche-designer-handbags.html repliche designer handbags

  • ____max50

    mackliy

    almost 4 years ago

    60 Comments

    oakley sunglasses for men's sunglasses are great way to make a statement whether you're out on the golf course, ski slopes, or just out on the town. The superior quality and construction of Oakley women's oakley shades means that each pair will perform for you. But which pair of Oakley women's sunglasses is right for you? Each pair is designed for a specific purpose and function and all Oakley women's sunglasses surpass the ANSI standards for clarity, refraction and prism. Check out some of the tips below to find the right pair of Oakley women's oakley sun glasses.

  • Photo_user_blank_big

    watches

    almost 4 years ago

    2 Comments

    Cartier is known for offering innovative and stylish products such as watches, wallets and handbags.com.cn">replica handbags. Cartier handbags.com.cn/Wallet-GUCCI-c-25_116.html">GUCCI Wallet replica and other products have revolutionized the fashion world and are very much preferred all over the world. It is brand that does not need advertisement and statement about its quality and achievements. However, these products are costlier out of budget for numerous people. In other words, due to high cost of its products, many people can only dream of owning a Cartier handbags.com.cn">designer handbags and wallet. This is why; Cartier handbags.com.cn/Marc-Jacobs-Handbags-c-10.html">marc Jacobs Handbags and wallets have gained much popularity in the market. Without compromising on quality, Cartier handbags.com.cn/Juicy-Couture-Handbags-c-12.html">cheap Juicy Couture Handbags also provide you with the same feel and look as the handbags.com.cn/Louis-Vuitton-Handbags-c-1.html">louis Vuitton Handbags replica. In other words, because of low cost and good quality, Cartier handbags.com.cn">designer handbags at discount prices are perfect for parties, special events and offices very much. These handbags.com.cn/Giverchy-Handbags-c-21.html">cheap Giverchy Handbagsare made up of so fine and quality products that no one can find the difference between designer and handbags.com.cn/Loewe-Handbags-c-14.html">loewe Handbags These bhandbags.com.cn/Dolce-Gabbana-Handbags-c-17.html">dolce Gabbana Handbags replica not only give you the same look as handbags.com.cn/Jimmy-Choo-Handbags-c-13.html">Jimmy Choo replica Handbags but also keep your budget balanced. Because of the low price, the demand of these handbags.com.cn/Prada-Handbags-c-6.html">Prada Handbags replica is increasing day by day. It is interesting that if you are going to present a handbags.com.cn/AH-Handbags-c-24.html">cheap AH Handbags to any woman, she will never know that it is a handbags.com.cn/Coach-Handbags-c-9.html">coach Handbags replica Price also plays a major role in the popularity of Cartier replica bags. These handbags.com.cn/Miu-Miu-Handbags-c-7.html">cheap Miu Miu Handbags are quite cheaper if compared to the designer one. In other words, you can get many handbags.com.cn/Wallet-Dior-c-25_118.html">dior Wallet in the cost of one designer Cartierhandbags.com.cn/Wallet-Marc-Jacobs-c-25_117.html">replica Marc Jacobs Wallet. Cartier handbags.com.cn/Christian-Dior-Handbags-c-15.html">replica Christian Dior Handbags provide you with the chance to luxuriate in highly innovative fashion of handbags.com.cn/Prada-Handbags-c-6.html">replica Prada Handbags without spending a lot of money. If talking about the manufacturing of the handbags.com.cn/Jimmy-Choo-Handbags-c-13.html">replica Jimmy Choo Handbags, then like designer Cartier handbags.com.cn/Marc-Jacobs-Handbags-c-10.html">replica Marc Jacobs Handbags handbags.com.cn/Fendi-Handbags-c-8.html">fendi Handbags are also made in all colors and designs by using the fine quality real leather. You can select your desired color and design easily. Whether it is for Cartier handbags.com.cn/Louis-Vuitton-Handbags-c-1.html">louis Vuitton Handbags, Cartier fake items, fake Cartier handbags.com.cn/Juicy-Couture-Handbags-c-12.html">Juicy Couture Handbags or fake wallets, purchasing of these items is extremely simple. There are numerous online stores offering you Cartier handbags.com.cn/Wallet-Marc-Jacobs-c-25_117.html">marc Jacobs Wallet replica, fake wallets and a variety of other replica products at easy-on-the-pocket prices with attractive discounts. In addition to Cartier handbags.com.cn/Versace-Handbags-c-20.html">replica Versace Handbags and wallets, online stores also provide you with replica products of some renowned names like Chanel, Fendi, Christian Dior, Gucci, Balenciaga and Chloe at reasonable price. Cartier handbags.com.cn">replica handbags not only give you the look of handbags.com.cn/Louis-Vuitton-Handbags-c-1.html">cheap Louis Vuitton Handbags, but also keep your budget balanced.

  • 3620245892_e09b0eaeb2_max50

    SRRobocop87

    over 4 years ago

    54 Comments

    Really good article thanks for the info!

  • Photo_user_blank_big

    Anonymous

    about 5 years ago

    Ummm, Shyla what do your comments have to do with the article??????

  • Chuck_max50

    CROM

    about 5 years ago

    30 Comments

    If being a Cop was your life long dream then you should have thought about that dream and "first kiss feel" before you did something stupid. Give life a few more years, grow up and show some commitment, you may earn a place.

  • 1979_max50

    Robocop33

    about 7 years ago

    14636 Comments

    Your juv. record is closed. Now they can still take it into consideration if you have felonies and you will have to tell them in your interview and polygraph. If you really want to be a police officer then study hard, get your HS diploma AND an AS at least in Criminal Justice and probably best to have your military obligation done with as well. That also helps you mature so that you can handle the responsibilities of becoming an Officer. It's a long hard road but it can be done if you are committed. Good luck.

  • Dscf5448_tn_max50

    Shyla

    about 7 years ago

    4 Comments

    hello i REALLY want to be a police officer1 but im also 17 and i dont know alot about how or even if i can be one cause a couple years ago i wasnt a vary good child, but when i turn 18 dosnt something happen to my record? its my life dream to become a cop. its my goal. when i just think about me acutally getting a chance to be a cop it feels like a first kiss! lol i feel strong and that nothing while stop me. i also wanna be a cop car when i grow up! haha just jokeing

  • Dscf5448_tn_max50

    Shyla

    about 7 years ago

    4 Comments

    hello i REALLY want to be a police officer1 but im also 17 and i dont know alot about how or even if i can be one cause a couple years ago i wasnt a vary good child, but when i turn 18 dosnt something happen to my record? its my life dream to become a cop. its my goal. when i just think about me acutally getting a chance to be a cop it feels like a first kiss! lol i feel strong and that nothing while stop me. i also wanna be a cop car when i grow up! haha just jokeing

PoliceLink School Finder

Save time in your search for a criminal justice degree program. Use PoliceLink's School Finder to locate schools online and in your area.

Get Info

* In the event that we cannot find a program from one of our partner schools that matches your specific area of interest, we may show schools with similar or unrelated programs.

Recent Activity

Us_flag_normal_1__max30
SE851 commented on: "Keith K", less than a minute ago.
Us_flag_normal_1__max30
SE851 commented on: "Homer Ferreyra", less than a minute ago.
Us_flag_normal_1__max30
SE851 commented on: "Samuel Schrader", 1 minute ago.
Us_flag_normal_1__max30
SE851 commented on: "Gray Panther", 2 minutes ago.
Us_flag_normal_1__max30
SE851 commented on: "Kevin Eagan", 2 minutes ago.