Training >> Browse Articles >> Firearms


Cops and Armed Citizens

Cops and Armed Citizens

Sergeant Betsy Brantner Smith

I grew up around guns. My dad, a farmer by trade, was also an auxiliary deputy with the local sheriff’s department so he owned a pistol or two. My cousins were hunters, and we always had a shotgun in the house that my father could get to if he needed to eliminate an errant raccoon in the garden or a family of moles tearing up our front yard. I was neither fascinated nor frightened by firearms, they were just a part of our lives in the rural Midwest.

When I graduated from the police academy in 1981, I was pretty excited about my “right to bear arms” both on and off duty. Although I was a patrol officer, I invested in a couple of concealed holsters for my big Smith & Wesson model 59 (completely the wrong handgun for a girl with the hands of an 8 year old, but that’s another article). I pretty much carried my gun everywhere. Young, single, and new to the “big city,” I spent lots of time in and around the Chicago area, enjoying the museums, the sports teams, the shopping, and of course, the nightlife. I never gave my safety much thought because (a) I was armed, and (b) I was usually in the company of other (armed) off duty cops. Life was good.

I’ve always enjoyed lively political discussions so I was happy to enter into debates about the Second Amendment and whether or not ordinary citizens really had a “right to keep and bear arms” as I continued to gain some patrol experience. At the time, I really didn’t understand what the big deal was. I was fine with people who were hunters, or enjoyed shooting sports, and even wanted to keep a “home protection” gun in their bedroom, but as a young cop, I was pretty sure I didn’t want ordinary, untrained people walking around “my” streets carrying concealed handguns. I mean, if everyone had a gun, how could we tell the good guys from the bad? If everyone was armed, wouldn’t people be shooting each other over parking spaces and other petty issues? Besides, I secretly (and selfishly) enjoyed the feeling of superiority in knowing that I was one of the few people allowed by Illinois law to carry around a loaded gun. Boy, did I have a lot to learn.

In 1989 I was invited to travel with the University of Illinois’ “Fighting Illini” men’s basketball team to the Final Four in Seattle, Washington. My uncle was the head coach so my dad and I were going to fly on the team plane. What a blast! Unfortunately, this was about the same time that serial killer Ted Bundy was all over the news, the “Green River Killer” investigation was in full swing, and I was obsessed with reading Seattle-based author Ann Rule’s true crime books. Not exactly a great time for me to be heading for Washington State. But hey, I was cop! I got to take my gun to Seattle, carry it everywhere, and feel safe and secure. Great for me, but it got me thinking about all those young female murder victims; many of them close to my age. What if one of them had been armed? Could she have saved herself and ultimately, many others? And back in Illinois we had our own famous serial killer, John Wayne Gacy, still in the news. He killed 33 young men and boys before he was arrested. Hadn’t they deserved the legal right to able to try and protect themselves to the best of their ability?

Two and a half years later, on October 16, 1991, the infamous Luby’s Cafeteria shooting occurred in Killeen, Texas. In what we would now call an “active shooter” situation, George Hennard drove his pick up truck through the front of the restaurant and was able to stalk, shoot, and terrorize the 80 lunchtime patrons, killing 23 and wounding another 20 before police cornered him and he turned a gun on himself. He’d been able to reload several times before police could arrive, and there were no armed citizens to challenge him. I was now a patrol sergeant and really starting to really re-evaluate my stance on citizen carry, and frankly, the Luby’s incident scared the heck out of me. After all, just like my state, the law in Texas at the time forbade citizens from carrying handguns. The Texas “serious crime” rate was 38 % above the nation average. After the post-Luby’s passage of the CCW law, serious crime in Texas has dropped 50% faster than the United States as a whole. Illinois, however, continued to prohibit CCW.

The whole citizen carry issue, often mixed in with the broader debate over “gun control” in general, has been terribly politicized and the debate rages on to this day. Yes, the United States is the leader in “per capita gun deaths among industrial nations,” a statistic that gun control advocates love to throw around. However, as most cops will tell you, the issue is a whole lot more complicated. One of the best resources out there is John Lott’srecently updated book “More Guns, Less Crime.” Basically, Lott concluded in an 18 year study that states who allowed citizens to carry concealed weapons saw violent crime goes down. Pretty logical stuff; the more law abiding citizens who train and arm themselves, the less victims we have. He has continued to study this issue objectively but passionately; every crimefighter should read his work.

My adopted home town, the city of Chicago, is a perfect example of Lott’s conclusions. We’re averaging 20 – 40 shootings a weekend, three Chicago cops have been killed this year, off duty, since May, and yet Chicago has some of the strictest gun laws in the nation! Who’s got the guns? The cops and the bad guys; and frankly, the cops tend to be out-numbered and often out-gunned. All the gun laws in the world aren’t going to keep thugs from owning, carrying and using firearms, so all the City of Chicago is doing is keeping law abiding citizens from legally obtaining personal protection firearms.

I’m retired now, but as I travel throughout the United States, training with and filming law enforcement personnel, I take advantage of HR 218; I am always armed, and I’m grateful for the privilege. I am now a firm advocate of well-trained, well-armed civilians, and this is an issue that police officers must get more involved in. With layoffs, cutbacks, workplace violence and the raging “war on cops” in the United States, we may have to depend on our citizens to step up, jump in, and help out in an armed encounter. After all, you don’t have to have a badge to wear a white hat and be one of the good guys. Stay safe!

  • Photo_user_blank_big


    almost 5 years ago


    I am a retired federal agent who will be taking full advantage of HR 218

  • Images_max160_sq90_max50


    almost 5 years ago


    But how do we separate law abiding citizens from nutjobs? i guess arming everyone is the general concensus here?

  • 061609_cop_max50


    almost 5 years ago


    I couldn't agree more with this article. Law enforcement cannot be everywhere and law abiding citizens should be able to meet force with force.

  • Finalfeeding161copy_1__-_copy_max50


    almost 5 years ago


    We need more of us to speak up on the CCW laws.

  • Barney_nip_it_in_the_bud_max50


    almost 5 years ago


    Great article! Long live the 2nd Amendment.

  • Photo_user_blank_big


    almost 5 years ago

    Excellent article, Sergeant. I've pointed out Lott's book to several of my friends, and they don't believe me until they see the data he's accumulated. After that, I have to remind them that no city, or even any area, is as safe as they think it is, or wish it was. The only insurance policy that works is having a legally concealed firearm on you, and knowing how and when to use it.

  • John_groh_max50


    almost 5 years ago


    Great article.

  • 1979_max50


    almost 5 years ago


    Great article Sgt. You have been a very positive influence on the LE community and even after retirement remain so. I am proud to call you my sister. Keep up the great work!

  • Photo_user_blank_big


    almost 5 years ago


    Just got my permit to carry in TN. Just waiting the 30-90 days for them to send me the damn card.

  • Thinker_max50


    almost 5 years ago


    Great article! My butt was saved once by a citizen who was armed and my closest back-up was 10 minutes away. I do believe however if civilians are armed, they should be trained first and have to attend periodic retraining just like officers have to. There is nothing worse than a person with a gun who does not know how or when to use it...

  • Picture_002_max50


    almost 5 years ago


    I loved this article, it is true on every single level. Could you imagine gun ownership for only police officers in the USA? Gun crime would be out of control, violent crime (just like the UK) would also be out of control. We have gotten to the point where it is time to start relying on armed citizens (armed security or not).

  • Picture_057_max50


    almost 5 years ago


    Yes, excellent article thank you for sharing it Sgt. Betsy Smith. Being I live here in New York and i carry a .45 as a citizen. I myself has been raised around them growing up and it is a good feeling to feel secure wherever I go. Knowing that there is always that possibility something could go wrong. With not only me or my family and friends, but officers and their families to. But just to know us as citizens would put our lifes on the line to save our officers to. Their has been a few incidents here involving our officers and if it was not for people like us. Those officers would not be here today with their families.

  • Photo_user_blank_big


    almost 5 years ago

    Man, I couldn't have said it better my self.........Thanks, and stay safe.

  • Battering-ram-full_max50


    almost 5 years ago


    Excellent article thank you for sharing your wisdom & knowledge Sgt. Betsy Brantner Smith

  • Honorvalor_max50


    almost 5 years ago


    Very good article..

PoliceLink School Finder

Save time in your search for a degree program. Use PoliceLink's School Finder to locate schools online and in your area.

* In the event that we cannot find a program from one of our partner schools that matches your specific area of interest, we may show schools with similar or unrelated programs.

Recent Activity

MarlyB posted in: "OH JUST", 1 minute ago.
MarlyB posted in: "OH JUST", 5 minutes ago.
darcieblosser1144 commented on: "Darcie Blosser", 8 minutes ago.
MarlyB posted in: "OH JUST", 8 minutes ago.