Print

News >> Browse Articles >> Officer Down News

-12

Murder Trial Begins In Philadelphia Officer's Death

Murder Trial Begins In Philadelphia Officer's Death

Philadelphia Inquirer via YellowBrix

October 04, 2010

PHILADELPHIA – For the fourth time in 10 months, Philadelphia police are steeling themselves to relive the murder of one of their own.

On Monday, prosecution and defense lawyers will begin selecting a Philadelphia Common Pleas Court jury for the trial of the accused shooter of Officer John Pawlowski, 25, the last city police officer killed in the line of duty, on Feb. 13, 2009, after just five years on the force.

The life of Rasheed Scrugs, 35, is on the line. A parolee from West Philadelphia, he has a decade-long record of arrests for theft, robbery, and gun crimes.

Scrugs is accused of initiating the fatal shoot-out with police at Broad Street and Olney Avenue, outside the SEPTA transit station. They were responding to a 911 call from a cabdriver who said Scrugs was threatening him.

Pawlowski got off one shot at Scrugs but was hit in the upper chest by a bullet that passed over the top of his bulletproof vest.

As in two of the last three trials of men who killed police, the District Attorney’s Office is seeking the death penalty if the jury’s verdict is first-degree murder.

In a first-degree murder case – where premeditation and malicious intent are key elements to be proved – Scrugs’ trial may hinge on the threat that witnesses say he uttered to the cabbie: “If you call the cops, I’ll shoot you and the cops.”

Pawlowski’s killing occurred during one of the Police Department’s darkest periods: seven officers killed in the line of duty, beginning with Officer Gary F. Skerski on May 8, 2006, another in 2007, four in 2008, and Pawlowski on Feb. 13, 2009.

His death touched off a storm of emotion in Philadelphia’s law enforcement community, still mourning the death four months earlier of Sgt. Timothy Simpson, whose car was hit by a drunken driver fleeing police.

“A career criminal.” “Cold-blooded killer.” “Unsalvageable.” Those were among the epithets Police Commissioner Charles H. Ramsey spat out to reporters the night Pawlowski was shot.

A month later, Municipal Court Judge Patrick Dugan ordered Scrugs held for trial on murder, robbery, and gun charges, calling him “a domestic urban terrorist” who “ambushed a police officer who was responding to a citizen calling 911 for help.”

20101004_inq_pscrugs04z-a_max200w

Rasheed Scrugs charged in the death of John Pawlowski.

Also compelling was Pawlowski’s personal story – his recent marriage to his childhood sweetheart, Kim, who was five months pregnant when he was killed. Their son, John III, turned 1 on June 11. The dead officer was the son of a retired police lieutenant and brother of a police corporal.

Much, if not all, of this week will be spent picking 12 jurors and several alternates who must be willing to consider imposing death by lethal injection if the evidence warrants, or life in prison without parole if it does not.

The prosecutors are Assistant District Attorneys Edward McCann and Jacqueline Juliano Coelho.

McCann, former chief of the district attorney’s homicide unit, is now deputy in charge of the entire criminal division. Coelho is a veteran homicide prosecutor who last year successfully prosecuted five North Philadelphia teenagers in the death of Starbucks manager Sean Patrick Conroy in a 2008 attack in a Center City subway concourse.

Two veteran Philadelphia defense lawyers are representing Scrugs. Lee Mandell, who defended one of the teens in the Conroy case, will handle the trial, and David Rudenstein will be “mitigation counsel” should the case reach the death-penalty issue.

Coincidentally, the judge in the Scrugs case, Renee Cardwell Hughes, handled this summer’s trial of two men for the murder of Officer Stephen Liczbinski.

That jury convicted Eric DeShann Floyd and Levon T. Warner of first-degree murder, but it deadlocked on the death penalty. Under state law, Floyd and Warner were automatically sentenced to life in prison without parole.

Floyd and Warner’s trial turned into a judicial marathon: four weeks of jury selection and three weeks of testimony before the July 28 guilty verdicts; two weeks more of testimony and deliberations before the men were sentenced to life in prison.

Mandell and McCann say they doubt Scrugs’ trial will take as long. In fact, they say, picking a jury could take longer than the testimony.

One reason is that the Pawlowski trial has only one defendant. And unlike Floyd and Warner, Scrugs – shot and critically wounded in the confrontation – did not make a statement to police.

Still, the possibility of a death sentence has a way of complicating a trial, and Scrugs’ attorneys were fighting it as late as Wednesday.

Rudenstein and Mandell, with help from death-penalty expert Marc A. Bookman, asked Judge Hughes to compel prosecutors to offer Scrugs a deal: plead guilty to first-degree murder, waive all appeal rights, and get a sentence of life in prison with no chance of parole.

The District Attorney’s Office has made such eleventh-hour offers before in death-penalty cases. The prosecutors’ refusal to do so with Scrugs was an “abuse of discretion,” Rudenstein argued.

Not so, McCann said, maintaining that there was no abuse precisely because the district attorney’s decision to seek the death penalty is discretionary.

Hughes denied the defense request, as well as one for a year’s delay in the start of trial. Rudenstein, she said, had not produced any evidence that the District Attorney’s Office unfairly decided to seek the death penalty in Scrugs’ case, or to refuse to offer Scrugs a plea deal.

“The trial,” Hughes said, “starts Monday.”


-12
  • Sfa_iv_max50

    revCCBeasley

    over 3 years ago

    2944 Comments

    No Question..No choice...THE BIG DEATH

  • Car6_max50

    Ahi

    over 3 years ago

    1990 Comments

    should be able to stop these people so they don't get that many chances...

  • Parkside_crest_new_12-15-08_copy_max50

    mmarchesi

    over 3 years ago

    2686 Comments

    Why give this POS the Death Sentence, in good old Pennsylvania he'll only sit on Death Row for years, get a book deal, and become some freaking hero to the bleeding heart liberal public, just as Mumia Abu-Jamal did.

    Find him guilty, and put him behind bars for the rest of his freaking life and be done with it. This way we don't have to pay for all his appeal hearings, not to mention all the pain the family has to go through each time it happens. Screw this POS by allowing him to rot in prison... Heck, we might even get lucky and another prisoner will shank his ass!

  • Photo_user_blank_big

    harrishsm

    over 3 years ago

    2 Comments

    It is a very sad day for Philly. all these years have gone by and it is still one of the top three murder caps in the country. Regrets to the fallen officer and his family.I grew up in Overbrook Park. Harris Mintz, Deputy Sheriff Retired,Los Angeles Sheriff's Dept.

  • Th_detective_max50

    Retleo

    over 3 years ago

    5524 Comments

    Another Career Criminal taking the life of a Police Officer! When are we going to start keeping these cretins off the streets so that they do not end up killing!

  • Blue2_max50

    RetCop9855

    over 3 years ago

    30 Comments

    I would pay money to push the needle on this scumbag!

  • Stmaarten2_max50

    bumperdog831

    over 3 years ago

    264 Comments

    kill this filth

  • Img_0123_max50

    agentattitude

    over 3 years ago

    2 Comments

    Sad that a penalty of death won't console Pawlowski's friends and family . . . but it's a good start.

  • Photo_user_blank_big

    rsironron

    over 3 years ago

    5220 Comments

    Death no questions asked.

  • Police_max50

    phantoms5656

    over 3 years ago

    36 Comments

    death... no question

  • Photo_user_blank_big

    senorwarrenv

    over 3 years ago

    8 Comments

    We have a trial in Salem Oregon, where a father/son put a bomb in a bank. OSP lost a Senior trooper and Woodburn police nearly lost their chief. They are blaming Obama for thier actions.

  • Photo_user_blank_big

    Anonymous

    over 3 years ago

    AGHHHH... Just wish I had a couple of minutes with the scum bag on "my own terms"... Just fry this piece of trash already..!!!
    R.I.P. Brother.. May God bless your soul.

  • Snoopy_6_max50

    Jonas

    over 3 years ago

    41146 Comments

    Too bad his life is still on the line!!!!!

  • Photo_user_blank_big

    Anonymous

    over 3 years ago

    bump curedgirls!, but dust off ole sparky to have on standby for an xxx crispy treat

  • Mardi_gras_cat_max50

    DonnaLynn

    over 3 years ago

    10484 Comments

    bump curedgirls!

PoliceLink School Finder

Save time in your search for a criminal justice degree program. Use PoliceLink's School Finder to locate schools online and in your area.

Get Info

* In the event that we cannot find a program from one of our partner schools that matches your specific area of interest, we may show schools with similar or unrelated programs.

Recent Activity

Star_max160_max160_max30
klamm143 commented on: "Rocky Windish", less than a minute ago.
Star_max160_max160_max30
klamm143 commented on: "Alan Garcia", 1 minute ago.
White_shirt_max30
uncledennis1 commented on: "Fireball (Old Dude)", 11 minutes ago.
Gods_team_max30
IowaNinersFan gave a thumbs up to The Article "Authorities capture man after 9 hours manhunt in Montgome...", about 1 hour ago.